Thanks to Mac, KE5QDA, I have had to reconsider the Digital Dilemma! He asked if I considered Winlink2K to be a digital mode. WELL, I had not even considered that question and I had to do some research on the topic. What I found out (after some soul searching) caused me to re-do my original Digital Dilemma post ... here's my thinking...
From the Winlink2K website:
"Winlink 2000 (WL2K) is a worldwide system of volunteer resources supporting e-mail by radio, with non-commercial links to internet e-mail. "
After reading this, I view WL2K as a pipeline rather than a digital mode of communication.
And I am sure there is LOTS of room for argument and discussion. Feel free to discuss because there's plenty of room for other opinions.
Any way, if this is my feeling on WL2K, then what about PSKMail? I reviewed the features list and came to the same conclusion. PSKMail is also PRIMARILY a pipeline to support email. It has some other features that kind of cloud the picture (mainly texting via APRS) but the main function is pipeline rather than allowing station to station communication.
There is WAY MORE information at each of these websites. WL2K is the "official" choice of just about everyone who is any kind of official.
Consider the following a VERY BRIEF introducton to these two programs ....
WinLink 2000 - Provides Email - WL2K Website
1. Windows (obviously)
2. Uses PACTOR 1,2, and 3 and requires pactor modem which is pricey.
3. Some proprietary features? ("The Winlink 2000 system, and Winlink user software is built, maintained and supported by the Winlink Development Team (WDT), your membership in the Amateur Radio Safety Foundation, and your tax deductible contributions.")
4. Recently introduced a sound card mode called WINMOR
5. APRS text messaging is possible as well as some packet usage for "last mile" coverage.
6. Lots of email servers world-wide. If you happen onto one of these frequencies, you'll probably have to move your QSO.
PSKMail - Provides Email - PSKMail Website
1. Linux BUT available in Windows emulator (puppy_linux)
2. Uses Fldigi
3. Modes - PSK250 with ARQ
4. GUI easy to use and provides email, APRS and Chat mode.
5. Upload/download email from internet and works with Linux email program called EVOLUTION.
6. While most email servers are in Europe, there appears to be a couple of email servers in the U.S. (one in San Antonio.)
... AR
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Hey Gene!
ReplyDeleteGreat article...I don't remember having to buy anything for Winlink to work, but, maybe it's because I'm connected to Cox and the email was going by way of my internet connection. It's been so long, I've forgotten, and, I've had a hard drive crash, so, it's all gone. :) Keep up the great work on those articles!
73, Mac